Skip to product information
Chunky NYC style cookies, best seller flavours, choc chip, white choc macadamia, nutella
1/3
  • Chunky NYC style cookies, best seller flavours, choc chip, white choc macadamia, nutella
  • Cookie M&M - Baking Memories with Matilda
  • Cookies - Gluten Free Best Sellers - Baking Memories with Matilda
Best Sellers NYC style chunky cookies
$45.00
  • Apple Pay
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Visa

Can't choose just one? We don't blame you.

  • A hand-picked selection of our most-loved NYC-style cookies — all in one box
  • Six thick, golden, freshly baked cookies with iconic gooey centres
  • Includes: Choc Chip · White Choc Macadamia · Nutella · Biscoff · Tim Tam · M&M
  • Made fresh to order using only premium, quality ingredients
  • The ultimate gift for cookie lovers — or a well-deserved treat for yourself (no judgement here)

One box. Six flavours. The best of the best, baked with love.

Cookie gift box Australia, best sellers cookie box, NYC style cookie box Sydney, cookies for gifting, gourmet cookie box, mixed cookie box, cookie hamper Australia, fresh baked cookie gift

Frequently asked questions
Allergens & Ingredients

Our cookies are made fresh and heat sealed to prolong shelf life.

Cookies are best consumed within 2 weeks.

For the ultimate experience we recommend heating your cookies in the microwave for around 10 seconds prior to indulging.
Delivery info

All orders are express shipped on Mondays and Tuesdays to ensure your baked goods aren't left sitting in a sorting facility over the weekend. Please allow 1-2 business days processing time as all baked goods are made to order.

Dispatch Day: Mon, Expected Arrival: Wed/Thurs

Dispatch Day: Tues, Expected Arrival: Thurs/Fri
Cookie Care

Our cookies are made fresh and heat sealed to prolong shelf life.

Cookies are best consumed within 2 weeks.

For the ultimate experience we recommend heating your cookies in the microwave for around 10 seconds prior to indulging.
Customers rate us 5.0/5 based on 27 reviews.

You may also like

About Us

Hi, I'm Tegan.

What started as an escape in a time of mixed emotions celebrating birth and grieving a loss has turned into a reignited passion for baking.

From baking for friends and family in rural NSW to launching at markets and now sending cookie boxes to every state in Australia.

Every batch is baked the same way I would for my own family - thick, soft centres and loaded with the good stuff (like chocolate of course)!!

Our Story

Take a look behind the scenes as we make some of our scrumptious NYC style cookies.

Express Shipping

Fast and reliable shipping to get your order to you as soon as possible
oven icon

Freshly Baked

Cookies are baked to order using only the finest selection of ingredients
5 stars

1,000+ happy customers

Over 1,000 happy customers from NSW markets & cookies deliveries Australia wide